Genre: Fantasy
This volume collects all the Bone comics in one fat graphic novel.
Everything about Bone is top-notch. This series is destined to be a classic. The story by Jeff Smith is interesting, well developed and paced very well. The characters are likable and are fleshed out with great care and detail. The story combines humor, suspense and dark fantasy into a tale that will hold your attention till the end, and like any good book is fun to reread too.
The art by Jeff Smith is absolutely excellent. The art is extremely detailed and pretty to look at. It at the same time injects a few characters like the Bones, who are drawn in a much more carton like style. These two looks however blend together very well to create one unique style.
A brilliant book, go get it.
Rating: 5 / 5, Highly recommended. A classic.
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Friday, May 7, 2010
Graphic novel review: Batman year 100 by Paul Pope and Jose Villarrubia
Genre: Superhero
The year x books put familiar characters in unfamiliar situations and hope that a good story will result from that. So in this book we have a society where everything is tightly controlled. Every human has been recorded and can be tracked easily by people in power.
The year x books put familiar characters in unfamiliar situations and hope that a good story will result from that. So in this book we have a society where everything is tightly controlled. Every human has been recorded and can be tracked easily by people in power.
Into this world leaps Batman, suddenly the authorities have someone they have no records of and are unable to trace and track. The book creates a bunch of mysteries, unfortunately they are not resolved in satisfactory manner. The main plotline of the book is serviceable, but without some strong and inventive writing it is incapable of raising this book above average.
The art is interesting. Whether you like it or not will be a tossup. I thought it was pretty good and enjoyed the style.
All in all though the book is below average. If you like all things Batman you would enjoy this more than other folks, for the rest there are better choices around
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average, only rabid fans need bother.
Monday, April 26, 2010
DVD review: In Search of History - Navajo Code Talkers (History Channel)
Genre: Historical documentary
Navajo code talkers were a group of Navajo marines who used their obscure language to create one of the only unbroken ciphers of world war 2. These men and their code played a crucial part in America's victory over the Japanese in the Pacific.
The documentary is extremely well presented. It explores the history of the Navajo. Sadly the recent history of the Navajo was persecution and horrific treatment at the hands of white settlers. Despite this treatment, when the US was attacked the Navajo rushed to volunteer.
The documentary goes on to explore the development of the cipher and its deployment in battle. It also touches on the discrimination that was rampant in the US around that time and how that meant the Navajo did not get the recognition that they deserved.
The documentary is presented with the help of interview of some the Navajo survivors. One of the daughters of a Navajo code talker, who now is a historians about this code, gives further insights and information.
An extremely interesting documentary, well worth watching.
Rating: 5 / 5. Great. Highly recommended.
Navajo code talkers were a group of Navajo marines who used their obscure language to create one of the only unbroken ciphers of world war 2. These men and their code played a crucial part in America's victory over the Japanese in the Pacific.
The documentary is extremely well presented. It explores the history of the Navajo. Sadly the recent history of the Navajo was persecution and horrific treatment at the hands of white settlers. Despite this treatment, when the US was attacked the Navajo rushed to volunteer.
The documentary goes on to explore the development of the cipher and its deployment in battle. It also touches on the discrimination that was rampant in the US around that time and how that meant the Navajo did not get the recognition that they deserved.
The documentary is presented with the help of interview of some the Navajo survivors. One of the daughters of a Navajo code talker, who now is a historians about this code, gives further insights and information.
An extremely interesting documentary, well worth watching.
Rating: 5 / 5. Great. Highly recommended.
DVD review: National Geographic: Everglades - America's Wild Spaces
Genre: Nature show.
The Everglades are subtropical wetlands located in the south of Florida. Everglades has a large amount of biodiversity and hence should make for a interesting nature show.
Just like most of the worlds natural habitats the Everglades are threatened by human settlements and human tampering of the ecosystem. The DVD touches on this and explains just what has been done to threaten the Everglades. It also touches on the restoration and conservation efforts that have started.
A fair bit of the DVD is spent following a German photographer, who is kayaking in the Everglades for the first time. Other times we are introduced to various biologist who are studying the Everglades, both to understand the natural system and also to see how best to conserve it.
Unfortunately not enough time was spent actually looking at the various plants and animals in the Everglades. The biologist are interesting enough, however the time spent following the German photographer is boring. The DVD is still interesting from time to time, since the Everglades is interesting. However by not showing enough nature this DVD is firmly in the average category.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average.
The Everglades are subtropical wetlands located in the south of Florida. Everglades has a large amount of biodiversity and hence should make for a interesting nature show.
Just like most of the worlds natural habitats the Everglades are threatened by human settlements and human tampering of the ecosystem. The DVD touches on this and explains just what has been done to threaten the Everglades. It also touches on the restoration and conservation efforts that have started.
A fair bit of the DVD is spent following a German photographer, who is kayaking in the Everglades for the first time. Other times we are introduced to various biologist who are studying the Everglades, both to understand the natural system and also to see how best to conserve it.
Unfortunately not enough time was spent actually looking at the various plants and animals in the Everglades. The biologist are interesting enough, however the time spent following the German photographer is boring. The DVD is still interesting from time to time, since the Everglades is interesting. However by not showing enough nature this DVD is firmly in the average category.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average.
Saturday, April 24, 2010
Graphic novel review: Predator omnibus vol 1
Genre: Science fiction.
The first predator omnibus collects a bunch of graphic novels which were written around the first Predator movie. While it is not necessary that you see the first movie to follow these stories, it would help put some stuff in context. The first three stories, which actually comprise the bulk of the book (some 300 out of the 400 page book), star the brother of the main character of the first movie.
The writing in this book varies quite a bit. The first 3 stories has some cringe inducing dialogue. This is mainly because the writers try very hard to give the book a Hollywood action movie vibe. Considering that these comics were created in the 80's and 90's, what you have is 80's action movie level of dialogue. Not good.
The last 4 shorter stories have serviceable writing. The final story however is pretty muddled with no explanations given for something that occurs in different era's of time.
The plot of all the stories is poor. It basically boils down to, Predator comes, humans and predator fight, The end.
The art all through the book is very good. However the art cannot rescue this book from the poor writing and non existent plot.
Rating: 2 / 5. Below average. Only rabid predator fans would enjoy this book.
The first predator omnibus collects a bunch of graphic novels which were written around the first Predator movie. While it is not necessary that you see the first movie to follow these stories, it would help put some stuff in context. The first three stories, which actually comprise the bulk of the book (some 300 out of the 400 page book), star the brother of the main character of the first movie.
The writing in this book varies quite a bit. The first 3 stories has some cringe inducing dialogue. This is mainly because the writers try very hard to give the book a Hollywood action movie vibe. Considering that these comics were created in the 80's and 90's, what you have is 80's action movie level of dialogue. Not good.
The last 4 shorter stories have serviceable writing. The final story however is pretty muddled with no explanations given for something that occurs in different era's of time.
The plot of all the stories is poor. It basically boils down to, Predator comes, humans and predator fight, The end.
The art all through the book is very good. However the art cannot rescue this book from the poor writing and non existent plot.
Rating: 2 / 5. Below average. Only rabid predator fans would enjoy this book.
DVD review: The end of the line, where have all the fish gone ?
Genre: Documentary about declining fish population.
This is a documentary about overfishing and how that is depleting the worlds fish stock to unsustainable levels. The documentary looks at the history of large scale fishing and its effect on various fish species. It also gives us some views on what could be done to avoid this decline.
The movie is aimed at encouraging consumer activism, and that is all well and good. I can't imagine somebody who does not care about conservation, reading the description of this movie and picking it up. However the creators of this documentary, from time to time make stuff over dramatic.
One of the ways they try to ratchet up the drama is by showing fish being butchered in a gory manner. That I felt was just muddling the message, were they encouraging conservation or were they trying to turn people into vegans.
All in all though the documentary is informative. I was startled to discover that when I choose farmed fish in a grocery store, I wasn't really buying something sustainable. While the creators could have done a better job, it is still a documentary worth watching.
Rating: 3 / 5, Recommended.
This is a documentary about overfishing and how that is depleting the worlds fish stock to unsustainable levels. The documentary looks at the history of large scale fishing and its effect on various fish species. It also gives us some views on what could be done to avoid this decline.
The movie is aimed at encouraging consumer activism, and that is all well and good. I can't imagine somebody who does not care about conservation, reading the description of this movie and picking it up. However the creators of this documentary, from time to time make stuff over dramatic.
One of the ways they try to ratchet up the drama is by showing fish being butchered in a gory manner. That I felt was just muddling the message, were they encouraging conservation or were they trying to turn people into vegans.
All in all though the documentary is informative. I was startled to discover that when I choose farmed fish in a grocery store, I wasn't really buying something sustainable. While the creators could have done a better job, it is still a documentary worth watching.
Rating: 3 / 5, Recommended.
Saturday, April 17, 2010
Graphic novel review: Elephantmen vol 1: Wounded animals by Richard Starking, Moritat and others
Genre: Science fiction
This book is scripted by Richard Starkings, with art by Moritat. Besides these two, the book has a whole host of other contributors. This book collects 1 to 7 of the series.
You can read a review of a prequel to this book here : http://sparrow-reviews.blogspot.com/2010/02/graphic-novel-review-elephantmen-war.html
The elephantmen this book refers to are half human, half animal hybrids created as shock infantry troops. The positives of this book is the art which is very good. Unfortunately the story and plot in this book are sub par. This book wants to tell stories involving racism and other bigotry, but does not manage to convey anything worthwhile.
There might be a overall storyline that Starking wants to convey, but these seven collected issues don't have much of that. The book is just full of filler material instead. The final pirate story is just plain terrible and pointless. Starking seems content with letting the gimmick of the half human, half animal characters carry this book.
Spend your money on something better.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average. Don't bother.
This book is scripted by Richard Starkings, with art by Moritat. Besides these two, the book has a whole host of other contributors. This book collects 1 to 7 of the series.
You can read a review of a prequel to this book here : http://sparrow-reviews.blogspot.com/2010/02/graphic-novel-review-elephantmen-war.html
The elephantmen this book refers to are half human, half animal hybrids created as shock infantry troops. The positives of this book is the art which is very good. Unfortunately the story and plot in this book are sub par. This book wants to tell stories involving racism and other bigotry, but does not manage to convey anything worthwhile.
There might be a overall storyline that Starking wants to convey, but these seven collected issues don't have much of that. The book is just full of filler material instead. The final pirate story is just plain terrible and pointless. Starking seems content with letting the gimmick of the half human, half animal characters carry this book.
Spend your money on something better.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average. Don't bother.
Monday, April 12, 2010
Graphic novel review: Kingdom come by Mark Waid and Alex Ross
Genre: Superheroes
Kingdom come is part of the Elseworlds series of comics from DC comics. These comics feature alternate history takes on DC's popular characters. The story is by Mark Waid and the art is by Alex Ross.
In this version, certain events have caused Superheroes of old to retire/fade away. The old crop of superheroes have been replaced by a new lot that do not value human life, this in spite of claiming to be defending and protecting humans.
The art and writing in this book is excellent. Both of them combine to build a great atmosphere in the book. The main characters in this book are developed very well as the book progresses. The plot of the book is well constructed and it proceeds at a fairly brisk pace.
The one negative for the book is that the resolution to the crisis in this book was underwhelming after all the build up. However in context of the entire book, I found that this did not bother me too much. The book is a good read and is recommended.
Rating: 4 / 5, Great, Recommended.
Kingdom come is part of the Elseworlds series of comics from DC comics. These comics feature alternate history takes on DC's popular characters. The story is by Mark Waid and the art is by Alex Ross.
In this version, certain events have caused Superheroes of old to retire/fade away. The old crop of superheroes have been replaced by a new lot that do not value human life, this in spite of claiming to be defending and protecting humans.
The art and writing in this book is excellent. Both of them combine to build a great atmosphere in the book. The main characters in this book are developed very well as the book progresses. The plot of the book is well constructed and it proceeds at a fairly brisk pace.
The one negative for the book is that the resolution to the crisis in this book was underwhelming after all the build up. However in context of the entire book, I found that this did not bother me too much. The book is a good read and is recommended.
Rating: 4 / 5, Great, Recommended.
Book review: Hooked, pirates poaching the perfect fish by G. Bruce Knecht
Genre: Non fiction.
Hooked deals with the story of Patagonian toothfish aka. Chilean sea bass. The main plotline in the book deals with a chase between the Australian patrol boat, Southern Supporter and Viarsa, a boat they suspected of pirating toothfish.
This plotline is well written and the author manages to convey a sense of excitement and a little bit of thrill to the chase. Keep in mind, the chase is basically one boat chasing another for period of months, so don't expect too much action.
Interwoven with the chase are several other threads. In one he explores the commercial discovery of the fish and how it ended up being such a popular fish in the US. Another thread attempts to gives us some background on a couple of fishermen on the Viarsa and how they got into fishing for toothfish. Yet another thread deals with some of the conservatory efforts done for the Patagonian toothfish. These threads and a few other fit in well with the book.
The final half of the book has a couple of narratives that don't quite gel with the book, one deals with the arrest of a American businessman dealing with toothfish. The other focuses quite a bit on a conservationist Daniel Pauly, including giving us details on his upbringing. The book is not large enough to give enforcement and conservation efforts any justice and these 2 seem to be a attempt to pad the book a bit.
The book itself is a light quick read. Since this is a non fiction book, I suspect a lot of people might not like the ending and will find it anti-climatic. I enjoyed reading the book and would recommend this to others.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended, a good light read.
Hooked deals with the story of Patagonian toothfish aka. Chilean sea bass. The main plotline in the book deals with a chase between the Australian patrol boat, Southern Supporter and Viarsa, a boat they suspected of pirating toothfish.
This plotline is well written and the author manages to convey a sense of excitement and a little bit of thrill to the chase. Keep in mind, the chase is basically one boat chasing another for period of months, so don't expect too much action.
Interwoven with the chase are several other threads. In one he explores the commercial discovery of the fish and how it ended up being such a popular fish in the US. Another thread attempts to gives us some background on a couple of fishermen on the Viarsa and how they got into fishing for toothfish. Yet another thread deals with some of the conservatory efforts done for the Patagonian toothfish. These threads and a few other fit in well with the book.
The final half of the book has a couple of narratives that don't quite gel with the book, one deals with the arrest of a American businessman dealing with toothfish. The other focuses quite a bit on a conservationist Daniel Pauly, including giving us details on his upbringing. The book is not large enough to give enforcement and conservation efforts any justice and these 2 seem to be a attempt to pad the book a bit.
The book itself is a light quick read. Since this is a non fiction book, I suspect a lot of people might not like the ending and will find it anti-climatic. I enjoyed reading the book and would recommend this to others.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended, a good light read.
Wednesday, April 7, 2010
Book review: Queen Victoria:Demon Hunter by A. E. Moorat
Genre: Historical horror/fantasy.
The tag line for this book goes - 'She loved her country. She hated zombies.' Based on this tag line I expected to get a 19th century, Buffy the vampire slayer book.
The book is not a 19th century, Buffy the vampire slayer. Nor is it a romance novel as some might believe, reading the blurb on the back of the book.
The book focuses on the time period just before Victoria's coronation to a few years after that. One might expect a 19th century Royal court to have various intrigues. In this book those intrigues involve Demons, Zombies, werewolves and such.
The book is well written with the author trying a fair bit, to humanise and build up the characters. For the most part he succeeds. The plot line in the book is functional and simplistic. There are no complex twist and turns here. There are a few sub-plots and surprises that keep it interesting though. The pace of the book is very brisk with events happening at a rapid pace. The book contains a lot of gore. I liked the gore in the book and thought it fit in well with the tone of the book. But a fair warning, if you don't like gore, you will find it gratuitous.
Quimby a side character in this book, ends up stealing the show. And that is the most severe failing of this book, since Victoria's character does not end up dominating the book, as one might expect of the title character.
All in all this is a light fun read as long as you don't mind the gore.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended
The tag line for this book goes - 'She loved her country. She hated zombies.' Based on this tag line I expected to get a 19th century, Buffy the vampire slayer book.
The book is not a 19th century, Buffy the vampire slayer. Nor is it a romance novel as some might believe, reading the blurb on the back of the book.
The book focuses on the time period just before Victoria's coronation to a few years after that. One might expect a 19th century Royal court to have various intrigues. In this book those intrigues involve Demons, Zombies, werewolves and such.
The book is well written with the author trying a fair bit, to humanise and build up the characters. For the most part he succeeds. The plot line in the book is functional and simplistic. There are no complex twist and turns here. There are a few sub-plots and surprises that keep it interesting though. The pace of the book is very brisk with events happening at a rapid pace. The book contains a lot of gore. I liked the gore in the book and thought it fit in well with the tone of the book. But a fair warning, if you don't like gore, you will find it gratuitous.
Quimby a side character in this book, ends up stealing the show. And that is the most severe failing of this book, since Victoria's character does not end up dominating the book, as one might expect of the title character.
All in all this is a light fun read as long as you don't mind the gore.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Graphic novel review: Savage Dragon, baptism of fire by Erik Larsen
Genre: Superheroes.
This a super hero comic. That entails a lot of beefy men and women with impossible proportions. There is also a lot of fighting and property damage. Erik Larsen, has however managed to construct a pretty interesting tale with engaging characters in this framework.
Larsen does the writing, pencils and inking for this trade paper back. The art throughout the book is very good. The lines are clear and the coloring is vibrant. The writing except for a few exceptions is good. The one exception that stood out for me was the title character giving a lecture about the police abusing their powers, and this whole thing was too preachy and contrived. All in all though, the writing through out the book keeps a pretty high standard.
This book is the miniseries that launches the Savage dragon series, it introduces various characters and lays out the ground work for future plot lines. The characters are developed well, and the pace of the book is brisk. I enjoyed reading this book and will be hunting down the other paper backs to see how the story proceeds.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended.
Note: The Amazon listing below is for a older trade paper back.
This a super hero comic. That entails a lot of beefy men and women with impossible proportions. There is also a lot of fighting and property damage. Erik Larsen, has however managed to construct a pretty interesting tale with engaging characters in this framework.
Larsen does the writing, pencils and inking for this trade paper back. The art throughout the book is very good. The lines are clear and the coloring is vibrant. The writing except for a few exceptions is good. The one exception that stood out for me was the title character giving a lecture about the police abusing their powers, and this whole thing was too preachy and contrived. All in all though, the writing through out the book keeps a pretty high standard.
This book is the miniseries that launches the Savage dragon series, it introduces various characters and lays out the ground work for future plot lines. The characters are developed well, and the pace of the book is brisk. I enjoyed reading this book and will be hunting down the other paper backs to see how the story proceeds.
Rating: 4 / 5, Recommended.
Note: The Amazon listing below is for a older trade paper back.
Sunday, March 28, 2010
Graphic novel review: Lost Squad by Chris Kirby and Alan Robinson
Genre: World war 2 / Fantasy / Magic.
Lost squad's premise is pretty interesting. It is 1942 and the Nazi war machine is in full flow around Europe. However in this version of history the Nazi's are using various mystical and magical means to gain a edge. Into this steps the Lost squad, a somewhat clichéd bunch of characters who go around foiling the evil Nazi plans.
This trade paper back contains 3 stories. The art in all 3 stories is black and white and is very good. The writing for the 3 stories is serviceable, with the first 2 stories being the best of the bunch. The character development in the book follows a predictable path there are no surprises. The storyline hints at a more complex back story for a few characters, however those hints are not expanded upon. All 3 stories are very average and it seems like the author is using magic to shore up insipid plot lines.
The final story comes through as a rushed attempt to have some sort of ending for this series. However because of all the unresolved hints from the previous stories, it feels very unsatisfactory.
All in all the book showed promise, but the writing in this book leaves the promises unfulfilled.
Rating: 2.5 / 5; Average, don't bother.
Lost squad's premise is pretty interesting. It is 1942 and the Nazi war machine is in full flow around Europe. However in this version of history the Nazi's are using various mystical and magical means to gain a edge. Into this steps the Lost squad, a somewhat clichéd bunch of characters who go around foiling the evil Nazi plans.
This trade paper back contains 3 stories. The art in all 3 stories is black and white and is very good. The writing for the 3 stories is serviceable, with the first 2 stories being the best of the bunch. The character development in the book follows a predictable path there are no surprises. The storyline hints at a more complex back story for a few characters, however those hints are not expanded upon. All 3 stories are very average and it seems like the author is using magic to shore up insipid plot lines.
The final story comes through as a rushed attempt to have some sort of ending for this series. However because of all the unresolved hints from the previous stories, it feels very unsatisfactory.
All in all the book showed promise, but the writing in this book leaves the promises unfulfilled.
Rating: 2.5 / 5; Average, don't bother.
Saturday, February 27, 2010
Graphic novel review: Strontium Dog - The final solution by Alan Grant, John Wagner, Simon Harrison and Colin MacNeil
Genre: Science fiction, 2000 A.D. comics
Note: While this book can be read even if you have not read other Strontium Dog stories, there is continuity in the main plot lines of Strontium Dog stories. So reading this book would spoil previous books in the series for you. I recommend you read them in order.
This book collects stories from 2000 AD progs 600-606, 615-621, 636-641, 645-647 and 682-687 (1988-90). It has one long story following the Strontium Dog Johnny Alpha and about 4 shorter stories at the end.
The art in the book is simply fantastic. 90 % of the pages are in black and white with some pages colored. The details and clarity in the art is stunning.
The writing in the book is good. It has a sarcastic, cynical tone throughout the book which fits in with a world devastated by radioactivity and one that has a persecuted class of mutants born due to the radioactivity.
The story in this book is serviceable, the tale told is entertaining enough. It is not however good or great. The art plus the story make this into a above average package.
Rating: 3 / 5; Above average, recommended if you like Strontium Dog stories.
Note: While this book can be read even if you have not read other Strontium Dog stories, there is continuity in the main plot lines of Strontium Dog stories. So reading this book would spoil previous books in the series for you. I recommend you read them in order.
This book collects stories from 2000 AD progs 600-606, 615-621, 636-641, 645-647 and 682-687 (1988-90). It has one long story following the Strontium Dog Johnny Alpha and about 4 shorter stories at the end.
The art in the book is simply fantastic. 90 % of the pages are in black and white with some pages colored. The details and clarity in the art is stunning.
The writing in the book is good. It has a sarcastic, cynical tone throughout the book which fits in with a world devastated by radioactivity and one that has a persecuted class of mutants born due to the radioactivity.
The story in this book is serviceable, the tale told is entertaining enough. It is not however good or great. The art plus the story make this into a above average package.
Rating: 3 / 5; Above average, recommended if you like Strontium Dog stories.
Graphic novel review: Elephantmen: War toys - Volume 1: No surrender by Richard Starkings and Moritat
Genre: War / Science fiction.
This trade paper collects Elephantmen: War Toys #1-3. This is also a prequel to Image's Elephantmen series.
The Elephantmen are animal-human hybrid soldiers created to fight in a futuristic war between China and Africa. The fight takes place in a Europe that has been decimated by a virus. The hybrids are made not only from fusion with elephants but also Rhinos, Hipppos, Crocodiles etc.
The art in this book is black and White and is pretty good. The scale of things seems inconsistent from time to time with the Elephantmen sometime seeming to be 25 feet tall and some time 10 feet tall. But all in all it is nice.
The writing is largely average. There is not much of a story told in this collection and what story is present, is predictable and largely uninteresting. This book feels like the team is milking its fan base.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, Only recommended for the rabid fans.
This trade paper collects Elephantmen: War Toys #1-3. This is also a prequel to Image's Elephantmen series.
The Elephantmen are animal-human hybrid soldiers created to fight in a futuristic war between China and Africa. The fight takes place in a Europe that has been decimated by a virus. The hybrids are made not only from fusion with elephants but also Rhinos, Hipppos, Crocodiles etc.
The art in this book is black and White and is pretty good. The scale of things seems inconsistent from time to time with the Elephantmen sometime seeming to be 25 feet tall and some time 10 feet tall. But all in all it is nice.
The writing is largely average. There is not much of a story told in this collection and what story is present, is predictable and largely uninteresting. This book feels like the team is milking its fan base.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, Only recommended for the rabid fans.
Graphic novel review: Cairo by G. Willow Wilson and M. K. Perker
Genre: Fantasy
Cairo starts very brightly. The black and white art is good. The characters we are introduced to, seem interesting and the writing leads us to believe that there is a good story to be told. The book remains strong till the mid point as the various plots and sub plots are laid out.
Midway through it starts to fizzle out. This starts with the characters, one finds it hard to have a connection with them. Their motivation's and the decisions that they take are too simplistic. Their break through 'a-ha' movements are childish. The author starts to touch on the current middle east conflicts between the Israelis and Arabs but does no justice to the complexities of the conflict.
The resolution to the various sub-plot and quandaries that the characters find themselves in is arbitrary. Magic is used as a convenient hammer to bang the plot lines closed. What starts out as a promising book ends up as a average book.
Rating: 2.5 / 5; Average, don't bother there are better books around.
Cairo starts very brightly. The black and white art is good. The characters we are introduced to, seem interesting and the writing leads us to believe that there is a good story to be told. The book remains strong till the mid point as the various plots and sub plots are laid out.
Midway through it starts to fizzle out. This starts with the characters, one finds it hard to have a connection with them. Their motivation's and the decisions that they take are too simplistic. Their break through 'a-ha' movements are childish. The author starts to touch on the current middle east conflicts between the Israelis and Arabs but does no justice to the complexities of the conflict.
The resolution to the various sub-plot and quandaries that the characters find themselves in is arbitrary. Magic is used as a convenient hammer to bang the plot lines closed. What starts out as a promising book ends up as a average book.
Rating: 2.5 / 5; Average, don't bother there are better books around.
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
Graphic novel review: Inferno by Mike Carey and Michael Gaydos
Genre: Fantasy
Note that this book is supposed to be written by Mike Carey. However in the book, the story credits list Gary Reed and James Pruett.
The first 4 pages of Inferno attempt to be mysterious and ends up being tedious. The first 4 pages are luckily not indicative of the rest of the book which feature good writing and a interesting story. Featuring a version of hell that is very different from the traditional sulphur and pitchfork version, the book follows the adventures of Travis who suddenly finds himself in this hell.
Travis doesn't know why he is in hell and the mystery about hell and Travis is built up nicely as the book progresses.
The introduction warns that the original run of the book was cancelled before its time and assures us that the ending is still good. That is absolute bollocks. When I reached the end I did a double take and thought that the book had some missing pages. There is no ending, most of the narrative threads are left hanging in the air. The book feels like a prelude to a greater story about this hell that was going to unfold.
This is a fatal flaw and turns what was going to be a good story into a average one. The black and white art by Michael Gaydos is good throughout the book.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, only get if you don't mind that this book does not have a proper ending.
Note that this book is supposed to be written by Mike Carey. However in the book, the story credits list Gary Reed and James Pruett.
The first 4 pages of Inferno attempt to be mysterious and ends up being tedious. The first 4 pages are luckily not indicative of the rest of the book which feature good writing and a interesting story. Featuring a version of hell that is very different from the traditional sulphur and pitchfork version, the book follows the adventures of Travis who suddenly finds himself in this hell.
Travis doesn't know why he is in hell and the mystery about hell and Travis is built up nicely as the book progresses.
The introduction warns that the original run of the book was cancelled before its time and assures us that the ending is still good. That is absolute bollocks. When I reached the end I did a double take and thought that the book had some missing pages. There is no ending, most of the narrative threads are left hanging in the air. The book feels like a prelude to a greater story about this hell that was going to unfold.
This is a fatal flaw and turns what was going to be a good story into a average one. The black and white art by Michael Gaydos is good throughout the book.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, only get if you don't mind that this book does not have a proper ending.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Graphic novel review: Just a Pilgrim by Garth Ennis and Carlos Ezquerra
Genre: Post apocalyptic science fiction.
This trade paper back collects the original miniseries that introduced the character and the sequel to that. The book is set in a world where the sun has expanded and killed a large part of the population and turned the world into a dry, arid place.
Into this world steps the Pilgrim. The Pilgrim is a religious fanatic who goes around doing what he believes is god's work. Ennis attempts to use the Pilgrim and other characters who exist in this world to debate about the existence of god. However these debates are not particularly clever or anything new and don't add any value to this book.
The 2 stories are pretty simple and straightforward. There is some humour throughout the book but nothing that would cause you to chuckle. The art of the book is very well done. Carlos Ezquerra's work complements Ennis's writing very well and helps set the dark and cynical tone of the book.
All in all the book has nothing new to offer and is pretty average.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, only for the fans of Ennis's work.
This trade paper back collects the original miniseries that introduced the character and the sequel to that. The book is set in a world where the sun has expanded and killed a large part of the population and turned the world into a dry, arid place.
Into this world steps the Pilgrim. The Pilgrim is a religious fanatic who goes around doing what he believes is god's work. Ennis attempts to use the Pilgrim and other characters who exist in this world to debate about the existence of god. However these debates are not particularly clever or anything new and don't add any value to this book.
The 2 stories are pretty simple and straightforward. There is some humour throughout the book but nothing that would cause you to chuckle. The art of the book is very well done. Carlos Ezquerra's work complements Ennis's writing very well and helps set the dark and cynical tone of the book.
All in all the book has nothing new to offer and is pretty average.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average, only for the fans of Ennis's work.
Graphic novel review: Steve Niles Omnibus
Genre: Horror
This Omnibus contains the following stories:
1. Aleister Arcane
2. Wake the dead
3. Secret skull
4. The lurkers
All stories are written by Steve Niles and each of the story has a different set of artist for them. The art style for all 4 stories varies quite a bit. The first one has a painted look. The second one is a more traditional comic book style. The third one is a gritty comic book style art. The final story's art style is hard to describe, best I can do is a stylised comic book style.
All the art is good however and is a strong positive for this book. Being a classic style horror book there is a lot of gore present.
The stories themselves are well written and contain good dialogue. However none of the stories are ground breaking or present anything new. The plot lines are predictable and there are very little surprises. Horror fans will get good entertainment from this book, for everyone else, this book is above average.
Rating: 3 / 5, Above average, horror fans will enjoy it.
This Omnibus contains the following stories:
1. Aleister Arcane
2. Wake the dead
3. Secret skull
4. The lurkers
All stories are written by Steve Niles and each of the story has a different set of artist for them. The art style for all 4 stories varies quite a bit. The first one has a painted look. The second one is a more traditional comic book style. The third one is a gritty comic book style art. The final story's art style is hard to describe, best I can do is a stylised comic book style.
All the art is good however and is a strong positive for this book. Being a classic style horror book there is a lot of gore present.
The stories themselves are well written and contain good dialogue. However none of the stories are ground breaking or present anything new. The plot lines are predictable and there are very little surprises. Horror fans will get good entertainment from this book, for everyone else, this book is above average.
Rating: 3 / 5, Above average, horror fans will enjoy it.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Graphic novel review: The walking man by Jiro Taniguchi
Genre: Relaxing explorations of nothing in particular. / Slice of life.
This book has very little plot, so if you need that in your book then this is not for you. That being said, if you are open for something unconventional then this book is a real treasure. The book is composed of a guy walking around urban Japan just observing things. There is very little dialog throughout the book and focus is really on the visuals.
The art in this book is excellent. The art is black and white and is basically pens with some shading. Each panel is constructed meticulously and is extremely detailed. The lines are crisp and everything is beautifully proportioned.
For a book that contains no plot the book flows really well. Not one page was boring. You can return to this book again and again and feel relaxed and happy.
Rating: 5 / 5, Highly recommended.
This book has very little plot, so if you need that in your book then this is not for you. That being said, if you are open for something unconventional then this book is a real treasure. The book is composed of a guy walking around urban Japan just observing things. There is very little dialog throughout the book and focus is really on the visuals.
The art in this book is excellent. The art is black and white and is basically pens with some shading. Each panel is constructed meticulously and is extremely detailed. The lines are crisp and everything is beautifully proportioned.
For a book that contains no plot the book flows really well. Not one page was boring. You can return to this book again and again and feel relaxed and happy.
Rating: 5 / 5, Highly recommended.
Graphic novel review: Britten and Brulightly by Hannah Berry
Genre: Crime / Murder mystery
This is a moody graphic novel, with some dark humor and some noir trappings. The book focusses on Fernandez Britten the sombre detective and his well, lets say unusual partner. Britten has had a very successful career carrying out investigations for jealous and/or jilted lovers. In fact he has been so successful that he had earned the nickname heart-breaker.
Now he is fed up with taking these kind of cases and will only accept a case if it involves murder. And so this mystery starts with Britten being asked to investigate a suicide that might actually be a murder.
The art has a stylised hand painted water color look to it. That and the dark palette help establish the sombre mood in the book. The art style fits in very well with the writing and plot.
The writing is intelligent and written in noir style. The plot itself is very good and entertaining. The surprises and plot twist are well planned and executed.
All in all a great book, definitely recommended.
Ratings: 5 / 5, Great, Highly recommended.
This is a moody graphic novel, with some dark humor and some noir trappings. The book focusses on Fernandez Britten the sombre detective and his well, lets say unusual partner. Britten has had a very successful career carrying out investigations for jealous and/or jilted lovers. In fact he has been so successful that he had earned the nickname heart-breaker.
Now he is fed up with taking these kind of cases and will only accept a case if it involves murder. And so this mystery starts with Britten being asked to investigate a suicide that might actually be a murder.
The art has a stylised hand painted water color look to it. That and the dark palette help establish the sombre mood in the book. The art style fits in very well with the writing and plot.
The writing is intelligent and written in noir style. The plot itself is very good and entertaining. The surprises and plot twist are well planned and executed.
All in all a great book, definitely recommended.
Ratings: 5 / 5, Great, Highly recommended.
Saturday, February 13, 2010
Graphic novel review: Northlanders book 2 - The cross and the hammer by Brian Wood and Ryan Kelly
Genre: Historical fiction
This book is a standalone story in the Northlanders series. This book is set in Ireland in 1014 A.D. and set during the Viking occupation of that land.
The book focuses on 2 people, Magnus a Irishman who is going around killing Viking officials and settlers and Ragnar a Viking nobleman who is sent by his King to track down and bring Magnus to justice.
And thats it, the plot is simply Magnus going around killing folks and Ragnar and his men running after him. There is no story to speak off. There is a plot twist at the end that is simply lazy and uninspired. The dialogue ranges from serviceable to bad.
The art is average, with everybody grimacing.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average, skip it unless you are a huge Northlanders fan.
This book is a standalone story in the Northlanders series. This book is set in Ireland in 1014 A.D. and set during the Viking occupation of that land.
The book focuses on 2 people, Magnus a Irishman who is going around killing Viking officials and settlers and Ragnar a Viking nobleman who is sent by his King to track down and bring Magnus to justice.
And thats it, the plot is simply Magnus going around killing folks and Ragnar and his men running after him. There is no story to speak off. There is a plot twist at the end that is simply lazy and uninspired. The dialogue ranges from serviceable to bad.
The art is average, with everybody grimacing.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average, skip it unless you are a huge Northlanders fan.
Friday, February 12, 2010
Graphic novel review: The V.C.s - Back in action by Dan Abnett, Henry Flint and Anthony Williams
Genre: Sci fi action.
The V.C.s is a revival of a old series from the British publisher 2000 A.D. In the introduction the author Dan Abnett states that this is not a re imagining but rather a continuation of the lives of characters from the old series. I have not read any of the old V.C.s stories and I do not believe that there is a need to read them to enjoy this book.
The previous V.C.s dealt with a war between the humans and a alien species called Geeks. This graphic novel focuses on a veteran from that war - Smith. There has been peace between humans and Geeks for some 50 years now and Smith we are introduced to is a old washed up relic facing a bunch of issues due to his war experiences.
All this changes when the Geeks launch a surprise attack on the humans and the veterans are suddenly thrust into war again. Now Smith needs to get his squad of Rookies combat ready to take on the Geeks.
The books plot proceeds at what appears to be a predictable direction. However the author slowly inserts a few intrigues that look to make the story interesting. For eg. there is a collective of extremely powerful aliens called the Polity who seem to be observing the humans and Geeks. What is their agenda ? There are a couple of other intrigues which I would not like to spoil.
The writing and dialogues are above average in the book. The story does start slow but shows promise of being good. I feel the art ranges from functional to being above average. All in all this is a decent beginning for this series.
Rating: 3 / 5, Above average, the series has potential.
The V.C.s is a revival of a old series from the British publisher 2000 A.D. In the introduction the author Dan Abnett states that this is not a re imagining but rather a continuation of the lives of characters from the old series. I have not read any of the old V.C.s stories and I do not believe that there is a need to read them to enjoy this book.
The previous V.C.s dealt with a war between the humans and a alien species called Geeks. This graphic novel focuses on a veteran from that war - Smith. There has been peace between humans and Geeks for some 50 years now and Smith we are introduced to is a old washed up relic facing a bunch of issues due to his war experiences.
All this changes when the Geeks launch a surprise attack on the humans and the veterans are suddenly thrust into war again. Now Smith needs to get his squad of Rookies combat ready to take on the Geeks.
The books plot proceeds at what appears to be a predictable direction. However the author slowly inserts a few intrigues that look to make the story interesting. For eg. there is a collective of extremely powerful aliens called the Polity who seem to be observing the humans and Geeks. What is their agenda ? There are a couple of other intrigues which I would not like to spoil.
The writing and dialogues are above average in the book. The story does start slow but shows promise of being good. I feel the art ranges from functional to being above average. All in all this is a decent beginning for this series.
Rating: 3 / 5, Above average, the series has potential.
Thursday, February 11, 2010
Graphic novel review: Strontium dog - The Kreeler conspiracy by John Wagner and Carlos Ezquerra
Genre: Sci fi / Adventure, British comic from publisher 2000 A.D.
This book collects 3 Strontium dog adventures from the 2000 A.D. comic series. The progs are 1174-1180, 1195-1199 (1999-2000). The subtitle of this collection, The Kreeler conspiracy is the first of three stories in the collection. The middle story is in black and white while the rest are colored.
The first story - The Kreeler conspiracy has a functional story, nothing innovative or new here. The art is above average.
The second story - Roadhouse has a pretty loopy story which I find is kind off a trade mark of 2000 A.D. stories. The story is again pretty average. I liked the black and white art in the story which I thought was excellent.
The third story - The tax dodge is again typically loopy and I think it is the best of this collection. It is not great but is above average. The art in this story is good.
All in all the collection is pretty average. If you are a Strontium dog fan, get it. For the rest of the folks I don't think its a good enough introduction to the Character.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average - Only fans of Strontium dog should consider getting it. Everyone else skip it.
This book collects 3 Strontium dog adventures from the 2000 A.D. comic series. The progs are 1174-1180, 1195-1199 (1999-2000). The subtitle of this collection, The Kreeler conspiracy is the first of three stories in the collection. The middle story is in black and white while the rest are colored.
The first story - The Kreeler conspiracy has a functional story, nothing innovative or new here. The art is above average.
The second story - Roadhouse has a pretty loopy story which I find is kind off a trade mark of 2000 A.D. stories. The story is again pretty average. I liked the black and white art in the story which I thought was excellent.
The third story - The tax dodge is again typically loopy and I think it is the best of this collection. It is not great but is above average. The art in this story is good.
All in all the collection is pretty average. If you are a Strontium dog fan, get it. For the rest of the folks I don't think its a good enough introduction to the Character.
Rating: 2.5 / 5, Average - Only fans of Strontium dog should consider getting it. Everyone else skip it.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Book review: Victoria Grandolet by Henry Bellamann
Genre: Period Drama set in the South of USA.
This book was originally published way back in 1943. The book is titled after one of the characters in the book Victoria Grandolet. The book starts with Victoria marrying into the Grandolet family and then explores her journey into this new experience.
The settings and people in the book are laid out pretty well though it could get a bit ponderous from time to time. I did not find the narrative thread in the book to be interesting nor were the characters or their interactions anything to write home about.
All in all the book was pretty dull and the only reason to get this is if you are curious about the author.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average. Not terrible but bland overall.
This book was originally published way back in 1943. The book is titled after one of the characters in the book Victoria Grandolet. The book starts with Victoria marrying into the Grandolet family and then explores her journey into this new experience.
The settings and people in the book are laid out pretty well though it could get a bit ponderous from time to time. I did not find the narrative thread in the book to be interesting nor were the characters or their interactions anything to write home about.
All in all the book was pretty dull and the only reason to get this is if you are curious about the author.
Rating: 2 / 5, Below average. Not terrible but bland overall.
Thursday, January 7, 2010
Book review: The Lost City of Z: A Tale of Deadly Obsession in the Amazon by David Grann
Genre: Non-fiction - Biographical, Adventure oriented.
This book came about from the authors obsession with a early 1900's British explorer - Percy Fawcett whom he stumbled upon while researching another story. Fawcett along with his son and his son's best friend disappeared into the Amazon while they were searching for a (perhaps mythical) City, Fawcett rather dramatically called Z.
To discover Fawcett's fate, Grann would himself have to sniff out the trail to Z. Grann estimates that around 100 people have already lost their lives searching for Fawcett and Z. Knowing this and despite being a self confessed city boy Grann decides to get on with the search.
The book in spite of the title is not purely focussed on the search for Fawcett and Z. The book also takes a biographical look at Fawcett's life. There are 2 main narrative threads here - first one is Fawcetts life and his exploration leading to his final expedition and the second one is Grann's pursuit of this story.
Besides the main narrative threads there are plenty of little stories, anecdotes and titbits that keep thing interesting and the book moving along at a nice pace.
I liked the writing style and pacing of the book, which combined with the shortish chapters and change in topics made this book a real page turner.
Rating: 5 / 5; Highly recommended.
This book came about from the authors obsession with a early 1900's British explorer - Percy Fawcett whom he stumbled upon while researching another story. Fawcett along with his son and his son's best friend disappeared into the Amazon while they were searching for a (perhaps mythical) City, Fawcett rather dramatically called Z.
To discover Fawcett's fate, Grann would himself have to sniff out the trail to Z. Grann estimates that around 100 people have already lost their lives searching for Fawcett and Z. Knowing this and despite being a self confessed city boy Grann decides to get on with the search.
The book in spite of the title is not purely focussed on the search for Fawcett and Z. The book also takes a biographical look at Fawcett's life. There are 2 main narrative threads here - first one is Fawcetts life and his exploration leading to his final expedition and the second one is Grann's pursuit of this story.
Besides the main narrative threads there are plenty of little stories, anecdotes and titbits that keep thing interesting and the book moving along at a nice pace.
I liked the writing style and pacing of the book, which combined with the shortish chapters and change in topics made this book a real page turner.
Rating: 5 / 5; Highly recommended.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)